{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Are Softening. What Buyers Can Negotiate Now

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

After more than three years of continuous year-over-year increases, the price of the average American home has finally begun to dip. Data from October reveals that the median sale price has fallen slightly compared to one year ago, marking the first annual decline since early 2023. Meanwhile, housing inventory has surged to its highest point since early 2020, pending sales have plummeted to a low not seen in over a decade, and approximately 20% of listings have experienced price reductions.

However, it's important to note that borrowing costs have risen once more. The average rate for a 30-year fixed mortgage has ascended into the mid-7% range recently, following a brief respite. Consequently, while buyers may have more negotiating power, monthly mortgage payments can still be a challenge for many families.

This scenario presents a unique opportunity. With sellers receiving fewer offers and experiencing extended periods on the market, the listed price and terms are increasingly becoming points for negotiation rather than fixed figures. If you're in the market for a home this winter, here's what you might be able to negotiate and how to approach it with the help of your agent and lender.

Understanding the significance of a minor price decline

A national decrease of under half a percent does not indicate a major market crash nor does it suggest that all prices are dropping. Certain high-value coastal markets with limited inventory continue to see price increases, while numerous larger metropolitan areas in both the South and West have registered declines of several percentage points compared to last year. The specifics of your local market should be your primary focus rather than national averages.

The data implies a shift in bargaining power. When homes linger on the market and multiple listings vie for a shrinking pool of buyers, sellers may become more amenable to discussions. This flexibility can manifest not only in price but also in the conditions surrounding the sale.

Price is just one factor

Many prospective buyers place all their emphasis on the price of the home, yet in a climate of elevated interest rates, the monthly payment and upfront cash needed at closing can be even more critical. A reduction in the sale price by a few thousand dollars only minimally impacts the mortgage amount. Using that same money in differing ways can sometimes yield greater benefits for your financial plan. Typical items for discussion in a sluggish market include:

  • A purchase price lower than the asking price
  • A seller contribution toward closing costs
  • Completion of repairs prior to closing or offering credit instead of repairs
  • Seller funds to reduce your mortgage rate
  • A closing date or timeline that aligns with your needs
  • Inclusion of items like appliances or window treatments with the purchase

Your realtor understands how local sellers are responding and can assist in determining which aspects will have the most significant impact on your offer. It's beneficial to focus on the most crucial requests rather than trying to secure everything available.

Managing closing costs

Closing expenses typically account for several percent of the loan amount in addition to the down payment. For many first-time buyers, gathering this cash can be the hardest hurdle to jump. A seller credit can alleviate part of these costs, allowing for a smaller cash requirement at closing.

Keep in mind, however, that there are restrictions on how much a seller can contribute based on the loan program, usually capped between 3% to 9% depending on the type of loan and your down payment. Additionally, the credit generally cannot exceed your actual closing costs. It's wise to consult your lender early to understand the specifics of your loan terms regarding these contributions.

Understanding rate buydown options

With interest rates now above 7%, one of the most advantageous offerings a seller can provide may involve assisting with your interest rate. There are two primary types of buydowns.

A permanent buydown involves paying discount points at closing to reduce your rate for the entire duration of the loan. Each point costs 1% of the loan amount, with the actual rate reduction varying based on lender policies and market conditions. If you anticipate holding the loan for a long time, a permanent buydown can be worthwhile.

A temporary buydown lowers your payment for the initial years. In a usual structure, the interest rate is decreased by two percentage points during the first year and by one percentage point in the second year, eventually reverting to the full rate thereafter. For instance, on a $350,000 30-year loan at approximately 7.34%, the monthly principal and interest payment would be about $2,409. With a temporary buydown, the first year's payment could drop to around $1,952, with the second year's payment approximately $2,176, before returning to the full amount in the third year. This setup may cost just over $8,000, which a seller might prefer to cover instead of lowering the sale price equivalently.

Be mindful that a temporary buydown is not a long-lasting solution. Ultimately, you will need to be prepared for the full payment once the discount ends, and lenders often qualify you based on the full rate. If interest rates decrease later, refinancing could be a potential avenue, but it's uncertain when that might occur.

Do not skip the home inspection

During rush periods, many buyers opted to waive inspections or minimize their requests to secure a property in bidding wars. In a more relaxed market, there's less urgency to forego such protections. A comprehensive inspection helps clarify the condition of critical elements like the roof, HVAC systems, plumbing, electrical systems, and foundation prior to making a commitment.

Should issues arise from the inspection, your agent can aid in deciding whether to request repairs, a price reduction, or a credit. Credits can be more straightforward than repairs managed by the seller, as they allow you control over how and when the updates are addressed, though the best choice will depend on the specific situation and your loan's stipulations.

Secure financing before negotiations

Having strong negotiating power is meaningless if your financing is uncertain. A seller evaluating two offers often favors the buyer whom they believe is most likely to complete the transaction. Before diving into serious house hunting, seek a full preapproval instead of a mere prequalification, establish your comfortable monthly payment limit rather than just the maximum loan amount, and obtain estimates from multiple lenders. Inquire with each lender about how they would manage a seller credit or buydown to avoid any future surprises.

Key questions to consider with your agent

  • How long do homes in this vicinity typically stay on the market, and how frequently are prices lowered?
  • Would a price reduction, a closing cost contribution, or a rate buydown be most beneficial for my budget?
  • How do the condition and history of this particular home influence what I might request?
  • Which contingencies should I maintain in my offer for my protection?

The takeaway

A softer market does not equate to inexpensive buying, especially with climbing mortgage rates. Nonetheless, it allows well-prepared buyers increased flexibility to negotiate terms that align better with their financial realities. With reliable financing, a clear understanding of your priorities, and the counsel of your agent and lender, you may secure terms better than what was achievable just a couple of years ago.

Rewritten using AI

Send Us a Message